JAMES SENSENIG, ND 

JARED ZEFF, ND, VNMI, LAC 

This column is transcribed from a weekly dwell dialog produced by the Naturopathic Medical Institute (NMI). The aim of NMI is to protect and promote the ideas of naturopathic philosophy by medical software, in your places of work and in your communities, on daily basis. This flippantly edited transcript (by Judith Boice, ND, LAc, FABNO) is the second a part of a 3-part dialog hosted by James Sensenig, ND, that includes Jared Zeff, ND, VNMI, LAc. It came about on October 18, 2017. 

Dr Carroll’s Botanical Formulations 

Dr Zeff: I studied with Dr Letitia Dick-Kronenberg’s father (Dr Harold Dick), and I received these formulation from him. These formulation had been developed by Dr O.G. Carroll. I’ve used them ever since I studied with Dr Dick. I depend on them. They work very effectively. 

That is how O.G. Carroll named his formulation – really, his spouse named them. The C Capsule is for constipation. The 50 Capsule is 50 % Gentiana and 50 % skullcap. The 42 Capsule is 4 elements wormwood and a pair of elements aloe. WW is wormwood. Particular G is Gentiana lutea. 

I’ll usually begin a affected person with 1 capsule per day. I’m not making an attempt to treatment constipation; I’m making an attempt to normalize the digestive operate so there isn’t any constipation. However within the meantime, the affected person is having 1 bowel motion per week whereas we’re making an attempt to repair their digestion. We’ve received to get that toxicity transferring. This capsule is a technique to try this. 

I’ll begin with 1 per day; if that’s not sufficient, I’ll go to 1 per meal; if that’s not sufficient, then I’ll begin including issues like electrotherapy or one thing else to get the intestine transferring – perhaps even needling. 

That is my fundamental abdomen tonic: Gentiana/Scutellaria. It was developed by Otis G. Carroll. Clever Girl [Herbals] makes these; I don’t suppose every other firm makes these, however I’ve them made for me by considered one of our medical doctors who owns a dry herb firm in Washington [Dr Rhonda Summerfield, Western Herbal and Nutrition, in Index, Washington]. 

Particular G is simply pure gentian. It’s type of a intestine tonic. It’s not solely abdomen, but in addition the intestine tract, together with the intestines. 

For a nervine, he used skullcap/valerian. I not often use this capsule as a result of I don’t like utilizing valerian a lot. Clearly, it’s a superb pal, it’s an efficient drugs, nevertheless it’s a bit druggy. 

I don’t like utilizing Ephedra. Ephedra is tough to get now, as a result of someone discovered flip it into methamphetamine, so the FDA doesn’t prefer it. However you may get it – particularly if you happen to stroll out into the desert just a little north of right here. I don’t like Ephedra as a result of it’s a harsh, “speedy” drugs. However typically it’s very helpful. 

Equally with valerian, it’s just a little too druggy. I don’t prefer it that a lot, nevertheless it has its place. Some individuals use quite a lot of it, however I hardly use any of it. For me, for a nervine, I might use pure skullcap…or relying upon the necessity, presumably skullcap, Melissa, and Avena. That will be a pleasant method. 

As for WW (wormwood), Dr Dick instructed me WW liquefies the mucus, so he used it in bronchial asthma. Relying on the scale of the kid or grownup, 1 or 2 capsules per day. It’s also possible to use that when there may be arduous, dry mucus within the lungs, a harsh cough, arduous to expel. Wormwood tends to liquefy the mucus and make it simpler to expel. 

The well-known 42 Capsule – I hate these! Some individuals really like them. The highly effective manner to make use of them is named a 42 Cocktail. That is when Dr Dick would use a 42 Cocktail: if somebody was having an MI [myocardial infarction], he’d give them a 42 Cocktail and do a variation of the hydrotherapy therapy, which he talked about on the film. He mentioned the 42 Cocktail will empty the abdomen. 

Let me handle {that a} bit. I had some dental surgical procedure some time in the past. They took a tooth out. It was an enormous deal, and I wanted no ache aid after the tooth extraction, as a result of I fasted. Nothing however water. On the third day, I began to eat, after which I had ache. The purpose of that’s, if you happen to’re having ache, and also you empty the abdomen, usually the ache goes down. So, Dr Dick would use a 42 Cocktail to deal with a migraine. You’re taking 2 of those capsules, empty them in a 1-ounce glass, such as you’d put a shot of whiskey in, put some heat water and blend it up. Drink it down. It’s probably the most foul-tasting stuff there may be. I hate it, nevertheless it’s very efficient. It hits the abdomen, and it empties the abdomen. 

You need to watch out with this method as a result of it can usually trigger an pressing, crampy diarrhea the subsequent day. As a result of I knew I used to be going to be standing up right here at the moment, I might not take this yesterday if I wanted it, as a result of then I might need to expire of right here actually fast! Not everybody has that impact from it, however I do, so I’m very cautious with it. I might not take this and fly on an airplane. I solely take this if I do know I’m going to have a simple time attending to a toilet the subsequent day. 

It’s primarily for ache, to empty out the abdomen. He would use it when somebody was getting acutely sick. He would give them a 42 Cocktail and a hydrotherapy therapy. For an acute flu, an acute influenza, an acute belly ache, he would give them that. In fact, if he thought the particular person was having appendicitis, he wouldn’t do that. However for lots of issues, he would – together with an MI. He handled a variety of MIs that manner. I haven’t had that have, so I can’t report on it. 

These are the first botanical formulation that Dr Carroll made that I do know of that had been handed on to me. Dr Dick-Kronenberg makes use of them; she makes them. I take advantage of them as effectively. 

Somebody from the viewers: The 42 Cocktail can also be actually good for coping with acute cholecystitis. For gallbladder ache, it might convey aid in quarter-hour. 

Dr Zeff: With that, I’m going to ask Dr Sensenig as much as end this part off, and something he desires so as to add. Then we’re going to have questions and discussions. 

Phytolacca, Chemotherapy & the Eclectics 

Dr Sensenig: I’m undecided what I can add to that, however simply a few ideas. Once you had been speaking about Phytolacca [see the July 2022 issue of NDNR], I need to level out that if individuals don’t know, it’s additionally a wonderful antineoplastic. A few of it’s possible you’ll be aware of the assorted natural formulation used for most cancers, considered one of them being the outdated Hoxsey method. It’s also called the Trifolium compound, or the crimson clover-Stillingia compound. This was a mixture of 8 completely different extracts, considered one of which is Phytolacca. It was initially a part of the US Pharmacopoeia (USP) as a therapy for folk with most cancers, however after the “invention” of chemotherapy, it was faraway from the USP. 

I agree with Dr Zeff on this factor: we take into consideration if these items that we’re instructed…that these items are poisonous herbs? They’re not poisonous, as a result of toxicity is a matter of dose. Something may be poisonous – together with water – at a excessive sufficient dose. 

As an apart: Speaking about standard drugs…there’s this assumption on the a part of the general public that a lot of what comes into medical apply is one way or the other associated to strenuous laboratory analysis and medical trials. Chemotherapy was borne of an extra stockpile of nerve gasoline after WWI. We had all this nerve gasoline in the US with nothing to do for it. Any person determined we will use it for drugs. That’s the start of the chemotherapy strategy to most cancers. 

The opposite factor I need to level out is that Dr Zeff was speaking about comparatively small doses, usually just some drops, or a couple of ounces, or a couple of drams. It dawns on me that a lot of it’s possible you’ll not know what he’s speaking about. 

After we had been in class a very long time in the past, our predecessors taught us botanical drugs based mostly on the Eclectic strategy to drugs – not the pharmacological natural custom, however fairly the Eclectic custom, a lot of which has derived into his lecture at the moment. That is the place these botanical extracts are used, not due to their constituents, however due to the entire plant and its vitality. 

Deborah Frances is a naturopathic physician in Oregon. She would say, “If you wish to know what Crataegus is used for, go sit below a hawthorn tree and speak to the tree. See how your physique is affected by the presence of that tree, or how your presence impacts you. You try this, you’ll know what Crataegus is sweet for.” 

The Eclectics used botanical medicines in a manner that began to maneuver towards the potentization that was being finished by the homeopaths, however the Eclectics couldn’t fairly get there. They had been just a little skeptical in regards to the succussion and the excessive dilutions (1 in 10), and so forth. Nonetheless, they used all their cures in comparatively small quantities in comparison with the physiological doses that a few of our faculties are instructing now. 

The indications for these botanicals, due to this fact, are the materia medicas of the Eclectics. They’re all on our NMI web site. We talked about it within the Very important Dialog. We’re speaking about well-known materia medicas, akin to Ellingwood, Felter, Lloyd, Prepare dinner, Culbreth – these are the basic Eclectic materia medicas. You can see that the indications for each botanical extract in these materia medicas contains the indications for bodily signs, together with a broader image. There’s an image for the herb. There’s not simply the pharmacological understanding of those numerous bodily constituents of the plant. 

Crops live beings. They’re our pals. They’ll speak. They’ll really feel. They know what’s happening. If we perceive them extra as people on a mission than as simply one thing that’s made out of stuff, and the way that stuff impacts us…that’s what a vitalist physician is all about. 

Apothecary Measurements & Dosage 

The Eclectics grew up in a time when the measurement system in drugs was the apothecary system. It had little to do with milliliters and ounces as issues are being finished at the moment. I’ve a number of pocket guides from numerous hospitals on the flip of the century from London and the US. That is the ebook that the physician carried of their pocket for fast reference for one thing. Each considered one of these has a botanical method spelled out for regardless of the situation is in apothecary measure. When you don’t perceive these measures, 1 ounce = 8 drams. So, once we’re speaking about drams, there are 8 drams in a fluid ounce. Many of those formulation use a couple of drams or a couple of drops. 

The dilution is clearly precipitated by utilizing a small quantity of one thing in a bigger quantity of a fluid. A few of these issues can be utilized in doses of ½ drop, and even 1/50 of a drop, and so forth. How do you try this? 

You place 1 drop in 50 drops of water, after which 1 drop of that combination is 1/50. I bear in mind having someone ask me, “How do you administer a ½ drop? How will you rely out a ½ drop?” You place 1 drop in 2 drops of one thing else, you then give them 1 drop. How do you administer 1/10 drop? You place 1 drop in 10 drops of one thing else, and provides them 1 drop, and so forth. 

I’ll provide you with an instance of considered one of my favourite Eclectic formulation from Dr Turska. It was his “go-to” liver method, and it was used virtually for every little thing. The indications had been what he referred to as “when someone had bilateral crud.” Fatty liver, lethargic liver – bilateral crud. “When doubtful, clear ‘em out.” 

His method was Chelidonium, 4 drams; Chionanthus, 4 drams; Podophyllum, 10 drops, all in 4 ouncesof water. 

That’s a typical method. There are books that survived in regard to utilizing these formulation: Helpful Prescriptions by Cloyce Wilson. He goes by prescriptions for a lot of completely different medical circumstances, however they’re all written within the apothecary fashion. 

You begin with: Rx = “take thou” (Latin); Chelidonium = drams 4; Chionanthus = drams 4; Podophyllum = drops 10. Then you definitely QSAD 4 fluid ounces. 

Then there’s a component to the prescription referred to as the signature, which is the way in which by which you utilize it. 

The way in which you place collectively the method is necessary. You learn the entire method. When you’re going to make a tincture, we’ve got Chelidonium, 4 drams; Chionanthus, 4 drams; Podophyllum, 10 drops; QSAD 4 oz. You understand you’re going to finish up with 4 ouncesbecause the QSAD is Latin for “at a amount enough” – of aqua distillata (distilled water) on this case. 

Everytime you QS one thing, it means “at a amount enough to achieve a sure level.” In lots of of those outdated formulation, you will note QS with one thing. It’s not at all times aqua distillata. In truth, in one of many materia medicas that I referred to, they’ve most likely 50 to 60 completely different sorts of water listed. You’ve aqua distillata, rainwater, lake water, river water, seawater, water from New York. 

When you’re going to make a method just like the one I discussed, you’re going to finish up with 4 ounces. Figuring out that you simply’re going so as to add 4 drams of Chelidonium, and 4 drams of Chionanthus, and 10 drops of Podophyllum, you realize from the get-go that you simply’re going to place about an oz of tincture in a 4-ounce bottle. That implies that ¾ of that 4-ounce bottle goes to be water. 

So, you fill the bottle first about midway. Then you definitely add your first botanical, combine effectively by shaking it up; you then add the subsequent botanical, and blend effectively; you then add the drops of Podophyllum; you then prime it off with extra water to 4 ounces. 

I’ve not seen this taught this manner wherever else. I bear in mind the primary time I had someone in my workplace from one of many faculties who took an natural tincture and put it in a 1-ounce bottle, perhaps half an oz of one thing, after which they added one other half an oz. I virtually fainted! 

Like, “What are you doing?!” 

“Properly, I’m mixing these herbs collectively.” 

“With no diluent? Are you kidding me? What are you being taught?” 

What the Eclectics taught us is that everytime you put tinctures collectively, you’re more likely to have a precipitate. You understand the outdated saying, “When you’re not a part of the answer, you’re a part of the precipitate”? Once you combine these formulation collectively, what’s precipitating? What’s that stuff? What worth does it have within the method? You at all times dilute, after which add one other and one other and one other to the diluent, after which prime it off. 

Many of the Eclectic formulation are based mostly on 4 ounces. The rationale they’re based mostly on 4 ounces is as a result of the common prescription is normally a teaspoon: TID = a teaspoon each 8 hours, or QID = a teaspoon each 4 hours, and so forth. 

A 4-ounce bottle has 120 ml; a teaspoon is roughly 5 ml, so you might have 24 doses in a 4-ounce bottle. However really, you might have 21 doses, since you account for some spillage, consider it or not. So, a 4-ounce bottle lasts 1 week at TID. 

That’s the way in which we realized to consider this. It’s in distinction considerably to what has been mentioned, however you at the least have to pay attention to this info if you happen to’re going to return to the Eclectic materia medicas, and the Eclectic formulae and perceive why they had been written that manner, even if you happen to don’t agree with me on the issue with the precipitate. 

To today, after I see someone combine two botanicals collectively, chills go up my backbone! 

This column, based mostly on the Very important Conversations of the Naturopathic Drugs Institute, will proceed in subsequent month’s NDNR. 

James Sensenig, ND, was a 1978 graduate of NCNM in Portland, OR. For over 40 years he maintained an eclectic apply in Hamden, CT. Through the years, Dr Sensenig held distinguished positions within the numerous naturopathic schools and the AANP. A champion of classical naturopathic drugs, Dr Sensenig acquired an Honorary Physician of Naturopathic Philosophy diploma from CCNM, and acquired quite a few awards for his dedication to instructing the ideas of naturopathic drugs. We invite you to take part within the Naturopathic Medical Institute (NMI) Very important Conversations, our annual Very important Gathering conferences, and plenty of different assets discovered at our web site: www.naturopathicmedicineinstitute.org.

Jared L. Zeff, ND, VNMI, LAc, is a licensed physician of naturopathic drugs and a licensed acupuncturist. Along with functioning as Medical Director on the Salmon Creek Naturopathic Clinic in Vancouver, WA, Dr Zeff teaches on the college at Nationwide College of Pure Drugs in Portland, OR, the place he was additionally Dean from 1988 to 1993, and holds a professorship in Naturopathic Drugs. Dr Zeff is a graduate of the College of California, NCNM, and the Emperor’s School of Conventional Oriental Drugs. He, together with Pamela Snider, is the creator of the AANP’s Definition of Naturopathic Drugs, and the Therapeutic Order idea.

Ads